Amendement 29 — art. premier #109

Closed
Pierre Pribetich wants to merge 1 commit from amendements/seance/29 into main
Contributor

Dispositif :

Compléter l'alinéa 12 par les mots :
« selon l'avis du comité scientifique visé à l'article L. 115‑13 »

Exposé sommaire :

Cet amendement du groupe Socialistes et apparentés vise à ce que la définition d'un bien militaire revienne au cas par cas au comité scientifique afin de savoir s'il relève du champ de la loi ou non.
Si le texte entend exclure les biens miliaires du champ des restitutions, il doit appartenir au comité scientifique de définir, au cas par cas, si un bien est considéré comme miliaire ou non. Sinon qui est a même de définir si un "bien saisi par les forces armées a contribué ou non aux activités militaires par sa nature, sa destination ou son utilisation" ? Ces questions sont sensibles et complexes. Il est essentiel que cette décision relève, pour chaque cas, des scientifiques, historiens, experts composant le comité scientifique.
Cette précision permet d'éviter d'exclure de fait tout bien militaire du champ de la loi et de faire en sorte qu'il revienne au comité scientifique de trancher si le bien en relève ou non.

Sort : Rejeté | Déposé le 09/04/2026
Source : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/opendata/AMANR5L17PO838901BTC2628P0D1N000029.xml

Co-authored-by: Marie-José Allemand PA840665@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Joël Aviragnet PA642764@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Christian Baptiste PA643143@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Fabrice Barusseau PA840829@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Marie-Noëlle Battistel PA342415@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Laurent Baumel PA606793@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Belkhir Belhaddad PA720362@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Béatrice Bellay PA842211@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Karim Benbrahim PA841315@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Mickaël Bouloux PA794094@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Philippe Brun PA793624@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Elie Califer PA795762@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Colette Capdevielle PA608264@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Paul Christophle PA840903@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Pierrick Courbon PA841295@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Alain David PA1008@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Arthur Delaporte PA793394@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Stéphane Delautrette PA795430@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Dieynaba Diop PA841919@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Fanny Dombre Coste PA606573@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Peio Dufau PA841633@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Iñaki Echaniz PA794854@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Romain Eskenazi PA842195@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Olivier Faure PA609332@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Martine Froger PA822617@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Denis Fégné PA841665@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Guillaume Garot PA333285@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Océane Godard PA840939@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Député PA841539 PA841539@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Pascale Got PA331973@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Député PA840171 PA840171@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Jérôme Guedj PA1567@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Stéphane Hablot PA841471@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Ayda Hadizadeh PA842263@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Florence Herouin-Léautey PA841813@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Céline Hervieu PA841853@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: François Hollande PA1654@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Sacha Houlié PA722150@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Chantal Jourdan PA643192@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Marietta Karamanli PA335054@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Fatiha Keloua Hachi PA795156@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Gérard Leseul PA774958@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Laurent Lhardit PA840765@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Estelle Mercier PA841463@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Philippe Naillet PA643157@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Jacques Oberti PA841107@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Sophie Pantel PA841381@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Marc Pena PA840793@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Anna Pic PA794270@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Christine Pirès Beaune PA608172@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Dominique Potier PA607553@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Christophe Proença PA841367@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Valérie Rossi PA840673@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Claudia Rouaux PA342196@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Aurélien Rousseau PA826635@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Fabrice Roussel PA841327@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Sandrine Runel PA841717@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Marie Récalde PA341981@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Sébastien Saint-Pasteur PA841243@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Isabelle Santiago PA774960@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Hervé Saulignac PA340343@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Arnaud Simion PA841091@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Thierry Sother PA841681@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Céline Thiébault-Martinez PA841893@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Mélanie Thomin PA793816@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Boris Vallaud PA719930@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Roger Vicot PA794494@deputes.angit.example
Co-authored-by: Jiovanny William PA720992@deputes.angit.example
Groupe: SOC
Angit-Diff: auto


PR reconstituée par angit ; les dates réelles figurent ci-dessus.

Dispositif : Compléter l'alinéa 12 par les mots : « selon l'avis du comité scientifique visé à l'article L. 115‑13 » Exposé sommaire : Cet amendement du groupe Socialistes et apparentés vise à ce que la définition d'un bien militaire revienne au cas par cas au comité scientifique afin de savoir s'il relève du champ de la loi ou non. Si le texte entend exclure les biens miliaires du champ des restitutions, il doit appartenir au comité scientifique de définir, au cas par cas, si un bien est considéré comme miliaire ou non. Sinon qui est a même de définir si un "bien saisi par les forces armées a contribué ou non aux activités militaires par sa nature, sa destination ou son utilisation" ? Ces questions sont sensibles et complexes. Il est essentiel que cette décision relève, pour chaque cas, des scientifiques, historiens, experts composant le comité scientifique. Cette précision permet d'éviter d'exclure de fait tout bien militaire du champ de la loi et de faire en sorte qu'il revienne au comité scientifique de trancher si le bien en relève ou non. Sort : Rejeté | Déposé le 09/04/2026 Source : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/opendata/AMANR5L17PO838901BTC2628P0D1N000029.xml Co-authored-by: Marie-José Allemand <PA840665@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Joël Aviragnet <PA642764@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Christian Baptiste <PA643143@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Fabrice Barusseau <PA840829@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Marie-Noëlle Battistel <PA342415@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Laurent Baumel <PA606793@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Belkhir Belhaddad <PA720362@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Béatrice Bellay <PA842211@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Karim Benbrahim <PA841315@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Mickaël Bouloux <PA794094@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Philippe Brun <PA793624@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Elie Califer <PA795762@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Colette Capdevielle <PA608264@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Paul Christophle <PA840903@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Pierrick Courbon <PA841295@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Alain David <PA1008@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Arthur Delaporte <PA793394@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Stéphane Delautrette <PA795430@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Dieynaba Diop <PA841919@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Fanny Dombre Coste <PA606573@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Peio Dufau <PA841633@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Iñaki Echaniz <PA794854@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Romain Eskenazi <PA842195@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Olivier Faure <PA609332@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Martine Froger <PA822617@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Denis Fégné <PA841665@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Guillaume Garot <PA333285@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Océane Godard <PA840939@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Député PA841539 <PA841539@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Pascale Got <PA331973@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Député PA840171 <PA840171@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Jérôme Guedj <PA1567@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Stéphane Hablot <PA841471@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Ayda Hadizadeh <PA842263@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Florence Herouin-Léautey <PA841813@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Céline Hervieu <PA841853@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: François Hollande <PA1654@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Sacha Houlié <PA722150@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Chantal Jourdan <PA643192@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Marietta Karamanli <PA335054@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Fatiha Keloua Hachi <PA795156@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Gérard Leseul <PA774958@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Laurent Lhardit <PA840765@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Estelle Mercier <PA841463@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Philippe Naillet <PA643157@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Jacques Oberti <PA841107@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Sophie Pantel <PA841381@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Marc Pena <PA840793@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Anna Pic <PA794270@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Christine Pirès Beaune <PA608172@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Dominique Potier <PA607553@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Christophe Proença <PA841367@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Valérie Rossi <PA840673@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Claudia Rouaux <PA342196@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Aurélien Rousseau <PA826635@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Fabrice Roussel <PA841327@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Sandrine Runel <PA841717@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Marie Récalde <PA341981@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Sébastien Saint-Pasteur <PA841243@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Isabelle Santiago <PA774960@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Hervé Saulignac <PA340343@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Arnaud Simion <PA841091@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Thierry Sother <PA841681@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Céline Thiébault-Martinez <PA841893@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Mélanie Thomin <PA793816@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Boris Vallaud <PA719930@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Roger Vicot <PA794494@deputes.angit.example> Co-authored-by: Jiovanny William <PA720992@deputes.angit.example> Groupe: SOC Angit-Diff: auto --- *PR reconstituée par angit ; les dates réelles figurent ci-dessus.*
Pierre Pribetich added 1 commit 2026-07-21 08:26:50 +00:00
Dispositif :

    Compléter l'alinéa 12 par les mots :
    « selon l'avis du comité scientifique visé à l'article L. 115‑13 »

Exposé sommaire :

    Cet amendement du groupe Socialistes et apparentés vise à ce que la définition d'un bien militaire revienne au cas par cas au comité scientifique afin de savoir s'il relève du champ de la loi ou non.
    Si le texte entend exclure les biens miliaires du champ des restitutions, il doit appartenir au comité scientifique de définir, au cas par cas, si un bien est considéré comme miliaire ou non. Sinon qui est a même de définir si un "bien saisi par les forces armées a contribué ou non aux activités militaires par sa nature, sa destination ou son utilisation" ? Ces questions sont sensibles et complexes. Il est essentiel que cette décision relève, pour chaque cas, des scientifiques, historiens, experts composant le comité scientifique.
    Cette précision permet d'éviter d'exclure de fait tout bien militaire du champ de la loi et de faire en sorte qu'il revienne au comité scientifique de trancher si le bien en relève ou non.

Sort : Rejeté | Déposé le 09/04/2026
Source : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/opendata/AMANR5L17PO838901BTC2628P0D1N000029.xml

Co-authored-by: Marie-José Allemand <PA840665@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Joël Aviragnet <PA642764@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Christian Baptiste <PA643143@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Fabrice Barusseau <PA840829@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Marie-Noëlle Battistel <PA342415@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Laurent Baumel <PA606793@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Belkhir Belhaddad <PA720362@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Béatrice Bellay <PA842211@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Karim Benbrahim <PA841315@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Mickaël Bouloux <PA794094@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Philippe Brun <PA793624@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Elie Califer <PA795762@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Colette Capdevielle <PA608264@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Paul Christophle <PA840903@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Pierrick Courbon <PA841295@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Alain David <PA1008@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Arthur Delaporte <PA793394@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Stéphane Delautrette <PA795430@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Dieynaba Diop <PA841919@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Fanny Dombre Coste <PA606573@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Peio Dufau <PA841633@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Iñaki Echaniz <PA794854@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Romain Eskenazi <PA842195@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Olivier Faure <PA609332@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Martine Froger <PA822617@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Denis Fégné <PA841665@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Guillaume Garot <PA333285@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Océane Godard <PA840939@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Député PA841539 <PA841539@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Pascale Got <PA331973@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Député PA840171 <PA840171@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Jérôme Guedj <PA1567@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Stéphane Hablot <PA841471@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Ayda Hadizadeh <PA842263@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Florence Herouin-Léautey <PA841813@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Céline Hervieu <PA841853@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: François Hollande <PA1654@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Sacha Houlié <PA722150@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Chantal Jourdan <PA643192@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Marietta Karamanli <PA335054@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Fatiha Keloua Hachi <PA795156@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Gérard Leseul <PA774958@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Laurent Lhardit <PA840765@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Estelle Mercier <PA841463@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Philippe Naillet <PA643157@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Jacques Oberti <PA841107@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Sophie Pantel <PA841381@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Marc Pena <PA840793@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Anna Pic <PA794270@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Christine Pirès Beaune <PA608172@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Dominique Potier <PA607553@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Christophe Proença <PA841367@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Valérie Rossi <PA840673@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Claudia Rouaux <PA342196@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Aurélien Rousseau <PA826635@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Fabrice Roussel <PA841327@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Sandrine Runel <PA841717@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Marie Récalde <PA341981@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Sébastien Saint-Pasteur <PA841243@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Isabelle Santiago <PA774960@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Hervé Saulignac <PA340343@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Arnaud Simion <PA841091@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Thierry Sother <PA841681@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Céline Thiébault-Martinez <PA841893@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Mélanie Thomin <PA793816@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Boris Vallaud <PA719930@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Roger Vicot <PA794494@deputes.angit.example>
Co-authored-by: Jiovanny William <PA720992@deputes.angit.example>
Groupe: SOC
Angit-Diff: auto
angit-admin added the
Rejeté
label 2026-07-21 08:26:50 +00:00
Pierre Pribetich closed this pull request 2026-07-21 08:26:50 +00:00

Pull request closed

Sign in to join this conversation.
No reviewers
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: assemblee-nationale/projet-de-loi-relatif-a-la-restitution-de-biens-culturels-pr-52635#109
No description provided.